how did prue die? I still haven't seen the episode in which...

Answer by piper
Submitted on 1/27/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
frite they had to save a doctor from shacks then prue yelled up tp phoebe so she could get the spell to vansh him. then when piper tryed to save the doctor from shaxs. But shaxs through her in to the wall. then prue tryed to save the doctor. shaxs did the same thing he did to piper.phoebe came down and killed shaxs. then she called leo. Leo healed them. then later every one found out they were witches. so a crazy lady shot piper. prue rushed here to the er. she died. while, phoebe was in the underground with cole that is when piper died. phoebe got a sorce to rewind time. then at the end the beging happend again. but phoebe was not there to call leo so piper lived but not prue and shaxs got the doctor.

Answer by 1#Charmed-Fan
Submitted on 12/29/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
I just saw the episode when poor Prue died. I even cried!!! See what happened was Pheobe had turned back time so she had to become a demon (only to save her sisters from dieing.)(when she did Prue was just about to be sooted in the hospital where dead Piper was.) anyway time is turned but Pheobe is stuck in the UNDERWORLD as a deman. So she is not there to help defet Shacks. So first Prue is thrown on to the ground knocked out, next Piper! Later (somehow Pheobe gets out of the deman stage) comes Pheobe up with Leo to find Piper and Prue both cold dead on the ground. He can only heel one (I don't know why only one but I know they were both dead.)(so of corse it's Piper.) Leaving Prue really dead.

Answer by Tizzy 90210
Submitted on 4/9/2006
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
First of all Piper DID NOT KILL Prue, Okay now to start the demon Shax came to kill a doctor because he either saved a person that the source didn't want him to save or he's going to save someone the source doesn't want him to save. Then when Shax got there Prue went to save the doctor and got thrown through a wall, then Piper was mad and went to save her sister Prue but she also got thrown through a wall, and Phoebe the first time said a spell that sort of kills Shax. Then the second time when Phoebe was supposed to say the spell she wasn't there because she was in hell underground with Cole and Leo. Then starting the next episode when Phoebe and Leo came back up from hell they were only aloud to save one person so Leo saved Piper because she was his wife and they realized Prue had already died about 4 seconds earlier. I feel so bad for everyone who knew Prue a lot especially Piper, Phoebe and Leo!!!!!!

Answer by Ava
Submitted on 7/3/2006
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
I also have seen what is apparently the episode just before Prue dies and the one just after ( the funeral, meeting of the new sister etc.) however, I seem to miss the actual death scene every time if there is indeed one. I can not believe given the chance to play a scene that rich, S. D. would pass it up. The answers above are not very convincing, a few are a waste of the brain cells used to read them, thankfully, it didn't take much. I would like to know if there really is one, it is the only one I want to see and am tired of checking on it. I do find it amusing to watch those women get younger and larger breasted as the years passed by though. The one who played Paige should have never dyed her hair. Her black hair made that beautiful skin just glow.

Answer by Fred Cooper Prue fan
Submitted on 8/20/2006
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
I know how Prue died. Prue was crashed into a wall HARD. the episode is called all hell breaks loose. ok this is what happend. they had a dr to save from the the domon shax, who killed Prue. so anyways, they were all talking, and Prue told pheobe to go upstaris to see if she can find anything else about the demon shax. so it was only Prue Piper and the Dr. downstairs. so while pheobe was upstaris. the demon shax busted into their door., and knocked down Prue and Piper. so the dr was the only one standing. So Prue was on The ground. So she got up and Said NO! and the demon was in front of the DR. and prue came up and pushed the DR. out the way. and the demon shax through out his Power and it hit Prue and crashed her to a wall. and anyways PHEOBE CAME DOWNSTAIRS AND SAW WHAT HAPPEND AND SHE CAST A SPELL ON SHAX AND HE WENT AWAY BUT NOT FOR LONG. ANYWAYS. PHEOBE called for leo and healed Prue & Piper. so then they went outside and shax followed them. so then, piper was killed cuz outside they were caught using their power, and then the charmed theme song came on. so while Piper was in the hospital leo came To Prue and saw that she was killed. So cole told tempis the demon to reset time. and he did but pheobe was still in the under worold with leo so she didnt get affected so the time was wear Prue and Pier was crashed into the wall. so Prue called for Pheobe and she didnt answer cuz she was in the underworld. so again Prue saw that the DR was going to get killed so she got up and said no and she pushed the dr out the way and she crashedinto the wall, and piper said PRUE! and then shax crashed her into the wall. so then shax left and he left them to die. So then after that Paige was in the next show. called charmed again. she went to the funneral, cuz she felt that it was related to the charmed ones she was she the youngest, and now its piper pheobe and paige piper didnt die with prue cuz she wasnt all the way dead like prue. and leo heald piper 1st and prue last and she didnt make it she died. and the reason why shannen doherty left charmed (prue) was cuz pheobe) alyssa milano wouldnt sign shannen a contract so she left the show on all hell breaks loose. well thats my story i have it on charmed season 3 too, shannen doherty (prue) was only in 3 charmed seasons.

Answer by Vicky
Submitted on 12/22/2006
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
ok actually she died at the hospital because they were exposed as witches when 2 of the sisters blew up shax in front of a news crew, and then a bunch of people came to their house to see them be witches, and then piper got shot because some crazy girl wanted to join their witchhood and prue got annoyed so she pushed her out of the way and then the girl went and got a gun and shot piper, and then prue was taking her 2 the hospital and gettin there by pushing people out of the way with her powers, so tehy sent the police after her, and then they got to the hospital and piper was barely alive or dead or whatever and so then the SWAT team so prue as a threat so they shot her and then leo arrived back just in time to save piper but not prue. and the whole time phoebe was down in the underworld trying to get cole or whatever, and she convinced the Source to turn back time but it didnt work or w/e. yep

FAQS.ORG makes no guarantees as to the accuracy of the posts. Each post is the personal opinion of the poster. These posts are not intended to substitute for medical, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. FAQS.ORG does not endorse any opinion or any product or service mentioned mentioned in these posts.

<< Back to: alt.tv.charmed FAQ

[ Home | FAQ-Related Q&As | General Q&As | Answered Questions ]

Question by Lissu
Submitted on 11/12/2003
Related FAQ: alt.tv.charmed FAQ
Rating:	Rate this question:
how did prue die? I still haven't seen the episode in which she dies but have seen ones after it. Soooo annoying!!!

Answer by Ficko
Submitted on 12/26/2003
Rating:	Rate this answer:
Shacks or woteva u call the blue weird guy kills prue,u no, blonde long hair,built muscly old blue guy who doesn't talk.

Answer by kt
Submitted on 2/23/2004
Rating:	Rate this answer:
omg i keep missing that episode im so mad

Answer by Jen
Submitted on 3/16/2004
Rating:	Rate this answer:
i know! i watch like every single episode but i was busy the day that they showed how prue died!!!

Answer by Jasmin
Submitted on 3/22/2004
Rating:	Rate this answer:
Prue tried to save an innocent from Shax in the manor. Sending Phoebe to the attic to find a vanquishing spell. But then Shax storms in and wants to kill the doctor but Prue jumps in front of him and gets herself crashing through a wall. Piper follows and they both lay bleeding and unconscious on the ground. Leo and Phoebe arrive too late. And can only save Piper and Prue passed by 2 seconds before! Thats it

Answer by killack
Submitted on 5/29/2004
Rating:	Rate this answer:
I cant bileave that i missed that episode i have only bin watching it for 5 months and y didnt paige join them before prue died then it will be the power of 4

Answer by dsd
Submitted on 6/19/2004
Rating:	Rate this answer:
She died

Answer by Piper_charmed_P3
Submitted on 6/21/2004
Rating:	Rate this answer:
omg i love charmed i wish it would come out on DVD

Answer by PrueRocks
Submitted on 6/30/2004
Rating:	Rate this answer:
They didn't actually have an episode in which Prue died, we can only imagine that she died just before Leo came to heal them and that piper didn't!

Answer by man
Submitted on 7/5/2004
Rating:	Rate this answer:
She died By piper killed her .

Answer by MANUEL
Submitted on 7/10/2004
Rating:	Rate this answer:
SHE FARTED

Answer by Dragonfly
Submitted on 8/18/2004
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
I have been trying to watch the episode where Prue is killed! last weekend i must have taped every episode of charmed without any luck!!! i dont get it... why couldnt Leo heal Prue and save her? I know that they wanted to get rid of Shannon in real life but i wonder if her death was very believable ?

Answer by PiperIsSoCool_Charmed
Submitted on 8/30/2004
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
Piper is aweome!

Answer by Suuz
Submitted on 11/16/2004
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
I know I hate it! I missed that episode too... it's too frustrating! Did she get a funeral? I can't believe that Phoebe and Piper can get over it in just one episode... that' pretty weird isn't it?

Answer by brad
Submitted on 1/3/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
Brad Kern from Charmed: Prue died cause Shax put her throught the wall and since Phoebe was in the underworld she wasnt there to say the vanquishing spell... And Leo and Phoebe thought the source had warned them about shax thats why leo came back to late and Prue was dead and of coarse the source did not warn them...... There is not episode explaining how Prue died but we wanted to make u guess and that was the right answer

Answer by Dr.X
Submitted on 8/3/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
She died a horrible death,and everyone cried.Blah blah blah,and they commit suicide.THE END OF THE HALIWELL SISTERS!

Answer by zoe
Submitted on 1/12/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
yeh on living tv there is never a program in between all hell let loose and charmed again maybe shannon left without making it

Answer by Karol
Submitted on 1/14/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
After watching the episode before and after 3 times, I became convinced that someone was deliberately holding back the missing 'prue dies' episode. It doesn't exist, they finished one series inconclusively with Piper and Prue mashed up, and started the next with Piper wailing and the funeral. Cop out, very disappointed. What happened, did someone just decide between series that Prue was out? I feel robbed.

Answer by I know all
Submitted on 2/3/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
PRUE COMES BACK - WAIT AND SEE -

Answer by SAMMY101202595
Submitted on 2/18/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
I wish I could have seen it

Answer by frenchy
Submitted on 3/1/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
I really liked Prue shes my fav i cant believe she had to die! but we all know its Alyssa milano'sfault! I wish she was the one who died!!!!

Answer by Coll
Submitted on 3/2/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
omg i can't believe i missed it! i know they were exposed when Phoebe was in the underworld and piper died by getting shot and then they went back in time and Prue tried to save Dr. Griffiths and got blasted through the wall along with Piper. Leo and Phoebe were too late. They could only save Piper

Answer by mandy
Submitted on 3/10/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
i have seen every single part of charmed i was too busy the day that Prue died

Answer by Marcella
Submitted on 3/17/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
I have been watching Charmed for a while, but I seem to always miss the episode of when Prue died! I think that TNT should show that episode. Charmed comes on everyday, and it was supposed to have started from the beginning, but I still haven't seen that episode. This is so FRUSTRATING!!!!!!!!

Answer by wiccan1234
Submitted on 4/5/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
Prue died when she came back from the vortex that led her to go back in time and prevent hers,piper's and phoebe's expulsion of witches on television the out of nowhere shax attacked and he hurt her and piper then leo arrived and he healed piper but, when he tried to heal prue but, he was already too late. too bad prue died she was witch material paige is merely an amateur.

Answer by Leigh
Submitted on 4/23/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
actually it had an episode where they both got blown through the window by shax but leo healed them both, they were revealed, piper got shot blah blah blah piper dies etc. etc. then Phoebe and cole and leo make this demon dude turn back time and then its gets half way through what had already happened when the episode finished when they are all still alive. then the episode after that it is her funeral and they meet Paige. it's so annoying! but you don't actually see how Prue dies.

Answer by nicola
Submitted on 4/24/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
what happened was shax fired prue through the conservatory/living room wall then he through piper through the wall. you saw them bleeding on thr rubble of the wall but prue died because she ripped the back of her neck open and lost to much blood

Answer by krissy baby
Submitted on 4/25/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
the first season is on dvd now it came out in jannuary they have it at amazon.com for like 30 bucks it's great

Answer by Shaun
Submitted on 5/28/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
Help i am tyring to find out what the actual episode was called when prue died so i can buy it and watch it if any one knows please email me at Shaunskinner1757@aol.com Thanks

Answer by charmed_1_piper
Submitted on 6/12/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
I am not sure what demond all I know is that piper and prue got hurt and leo only had time to save piper and prue bit the dust because alysa milano and shannen doherty hated eachother so alysa said me or her and alysa milano won the fight and shannen doherty was kicked off another show and I still have not seen the episode when prue is killed and as soon as that season comes out on dvd it is mine!

Answer by rose
Submitted on 6/20/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
ooooooooo!she died

Answer by Roxy
Submitted on 6/24/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
I hate it that prue died with her it is much better!

Answer by BoB
Submitted on 7/5/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
She died because she was ugly

Answer by ara
Submitted on 7/11/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
Shax comes in when Prue sent phoebe to find a vanquishing spell Prue trying 2 save the doctor gets in front of shax and piper and Prue lay on the ground unconscious and Leo saves piper then Prue but he is 2 late 4 Prue

Answer by chris
Submitted on 7/27/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
see i missed that episode i have the first season on DVD

Answer by Jenna
Submitted on 8/1/2005
Rating: Not yet rated	Rate this answer:
OMG!!! I love Charmed, but I was gone the day they showed the episode where Prue died!!! And the people never show it anymore and I'm so mad!!! And Who is Paige...like i mean where did she come from, and how is she their half sister??????