background image
The incident command post provided a clear view of and access to the crash
site, allowing the incident commander to assess the situation at all times.
195
At 9:55, the incident commander ordered an evacuation of the Pentagon
impact area because a partial collapse was imminent; it occurred at 9:57, and
no first responder was injured.
196
At 10:15, the incident commander ordered a full evacuation of the com-
mand post because of the warning of an approaching hijacked aircraft passed
along by the FBI.This was the first of three evacuations caused by reports of
incoming aircraft, and the evacuation order was well communicated and well
coordinated.
197
Several factors facilitated the response to this incident, and distinguish it
from the far more difficult task in New York.There was a single incident, and
it was not 1,000 feet above ground. The incident site was relatively easy to
secure and contain, and there were no other buildings in the immediate area.
There was no collateral damage beyond the Pentagon.
198
Yet the Pentagon response encountered difficulties that echo those expe-
rienced in New York. As the "Arlington County: After-Action Report" notes,
there were significant problems with both self-dispatching and communica-
tions: "Organizations, response units, and individuals proceeding on their own
initiative directly to an incident site, without the knowledge and permission
of the host jurisdiction and the Incident Commander, complicate the exer-
cise of command, increase the risks faced by bonafide responders, and exac-
erbate the challenge of accountability."With respect to communications, the
report concludes: "Almost all aspects of communications continue to be prob-
lematic, from initial notification to tactical operations. Cellular telephones
were of little value. . . . Radio channels were initially oversaturated. . . . Pagers
seemed to be the most reliable means of notification when available and used,
but most firefighters are not issued pagers."
199
It is a fair inference, given the differing situations in New York City and
Northern Virginia, that the problems in command, control, and communica-
tions that occurred at both sites will likely recur in any emergency of similar
scale. The task looking forward is to enable first responders to respond in a
coordinated manner with the greatest possible awareness of the situation.
9.4 ANALYSIS
Like the national defense effort described in chapter 1, the emergency
response to the attacks on 9/11 was necessarily improvised. In New York, the
FDNY, NYPD, the Port Authority, WTC employees, and the building occu-
pants themselves did their best to cope with the effects of an unimaginable
catastrophe--unfolding furiously over a mere 102 minutes--for which they
were unprepared in terms of both training and mindset. As a result of the
HEROISM AND HORROR
315
Final 8-9.5pp 7/17/04 1:24 PM Page 315