background image
In the spring, reporting on terrorism surged dramatically. In chapter 8, we
will explore this reporting and the ways agencies responded.These increasingly
alarming reports, briefed to the President and top officials, became part of the
context in which the new administration weighed its options for policy on
al Qaeda.
Except for a few reports that the CSG considered and apparently judged
to be unreliable, none of these pointed specifically to possible al Qaeda
action inside the United States--although the CSG continued to be con-
cerned about the domestic threat. The mosaic of threat intelligence came
from the Counterterrorist Center, which collected only abroad. Its reports
were not supplemented by reports from the FBI. Clarke had expressed con-
cern about an al Qaeda presence in the United States, and he worried about
an attack on the White House by "Hizbollah, Hamas, al Qida and other ter-
rorist organizations."
194
In May, President Bush announced that Vice President Cheney would him-
self lead an effort looking at preparations for managing a possible attack by
weapons of mass destruction and at more general problems of national pre-
paredness.The next few months were mainly spent organizing the effort and
bringing an admiral from the Sixth Fleet back to Washington to manage it.The
Vice President's task force was just getting under way when the 9/11 attack
occurred.
195
On May 29, at Tenet's request, Rice and Tenet converted their usual weekly
meeting into a broader discussion on al Qaeda; participants included Clarke,
CTC chief Cofer Black, and "Richard," a group chief with authority over the
Bin Ladin unit. Rice asked about "taking the offensive" and whether any
approach could be made to influence Bin Ladin or the Taliban. Clarke and
Black replied that the CIA's ongoing disruption activities were "taking the
offensive" and that Bin Ladin could not be deterred. A wide-ranging discus-
sion then ensued about "breaking the back" of Bin Ladin's organization.
196
Tenet emphasized the ambitious plans for covert action that the CIA had
developed in December 2000. In discussing the draft authorities for this pro-
gram in March, CIA officials had pointed out that the spending level envisioned
for these plans was larger than the CIA's entire current budget for counterter-
rorism covert action. It would be a multiyear program, requiring such levels of
spending for about five years.
197
The CIA official, "Richard," told us that Rice "got it." He said she agreed
with his conclusions about what needed to be done, although he complained
to us that the policy process did not follow through quickly enough.
198
Clarke
and Black were asked to develop a range of options for attacking Bin Ladin's
organization, from the least to most ambitious.
199
Rice and Hadley asked Clarke and his staff to draw up the new presiden-
tial directive. On June 7, Hadley circulated the first draft, describing it as "an
admittedly ambitious" program for confronting al Qaeda.
200
The draft
NSPD's goal was to "eliminate the al Qida network of terrorist groups as a
204
THE 9/11 COMMISSION REPORT
Final 5-7.5pp 7/17/04 11:46 AM Page 204