background image
`we will respond at a time, place and manner of our own choosing' and not be
forced into knee-jerk responses."
177
Before Vice President Cheney visited the
CIA in mid-February, Clarke sent him a memo--outside the usual White
House document-management system--suggesting that he ask CIA officials
"what additional information is needed before CIA can definitively conclude
that al-Qida was responsible" for the Cole.
178
In March 2001, the CIA's brief-
ing slides for Rice were still describing the CIA's "preliminary judgment" that
a "strong circumstantial case" could be made against al Qaeda but noting that
the CIA continued to lack "conclusive information on external command and
control" of the attack.
179
Clarke and his aides continued to provide Rice and
Hadley with evidence reinforcing the case against al Qaeda and urging action.
180
The President explained to us that he had been concerned lest an ineffec-
tual air strike just serve to give Bin Ladin a propaganda advantage. He said he
had not been told about Clinton administration warnings to the Taliban.The
President told us that he had concluded that the United States must use ground
forces for a job like this.
181
Rice told us that there was never a formal, recorded decision not to retali-
ate specifically for the Cole attack. Exchanges with the President, between the
President and Tenet, and between herself and Powell and Rumsfeld had pro-
duced a consensus that "tit-for-tat" responses were likely to be counterproduc-
tive. This had been the case, she thought, with the cruise missile strikes of
August 1998.The new team at the Pentagon did not push for action. On the
contrary, Rumsfeld thought that too much time had passed and his deputy, Paul
Wolfowitz, thought that the Cole attack was "stale." Hadley said that in the end,
the administration's real response to the Cole would be a new, more aggressive
strategy against al Qaeda.
182
The administration decided to propose to Congress a substantial increase in
counterterrorism funding for national security agencies, including the CIA and
the FBI.This included a 27 percent increase in counterterrorism funding for
the CIA.
183
Starting a Review
In early March, the administration postponed action on proposals for increas-
ing aid to the Northern Alliance and the Uzbeks. Rice noted at the time that
a more wide-ranging examination of policy toward Afghanistan was needed
first. She wanted the review very soon.
184
Rice and others recalled the President saying, "I'm tired of swatting at
flies."
185
The President reportedly also said,"I'm tired of playing defense. I want
to play offense. I want to take the fight to the terrorists."
186
President Bush
explained to us that he had become impatient. He apparently had heard propos-
als for rolling back al Qaeda but felt that catching terrorists one by one or even
cell by cell was not an approach likely to succeed in the long run. At the same
time, he said, he understood that policy had to be developed slowly so that diplo-
macy and financial and military measures could mesh with one another.
187
202
THE 9/11 COMMISSION REPORT
Final 5-7.5pp 7/17/04 11:46 AM Page 202