Top Document: soc.culture.jewish.parenting FAQ: Newsgroup Policies and Procedures Previous Document: 1.5. What topics are *not* appropriate for soc.culture.jewish.parenting? Next Document: 1.7. How should I respond to inappropriate articles? See reader questions & answers on this topic! - Help others by sharing your knowledge Attacks on parents' decision to circumcise their sons will be rejected; however, non-judgemental questions regarding the practice of ritual circumcision in a Jewish context are permitted. We are not implying that all Jews are circumcised, or that all Jews choose to circumcise their children (though that is certainly true for the majority). We want both to protect the circumcised from the anti-circumcision extremists, and to protect those chosing not to circumcise from the "you're not Jewish" flames. The moderators would absolutely and categorically reject any post that called into question the Jewishness of a parent who does not circumcise their son. In addition, because we will not permit flames, S.C.J.P is a singularly accepting place to discuss circumcision even if one's personal decision is NOT to. That is, one could discuss how to reconcile feelings regarding the decision to or not to circumcise, as they relate to the issue of whether one should under Jewish law, without inciting the wrath of either the various anti-circumcision factions or the wrath of those Jews for whom *not* circumcising would be sacreligious. Moderators would, in fact, reject responses that attacked a post for *either* reason. v In particular, it is intended that discussion of all aspects of circumcision is permitted EXCEPT for the following areas: o No discussions of pro/con arguments that are unreleated to the Jewish aspects of the decision; that is, any "Should I circumcise" discussion must be grounded in reconciling that decision with traditional Jewish practice. o No attacks are permitted upon those that make a circumcision decision, be it to take the traditional route (from the anti-circumcision folks), or from those that chose the non-traditional route (from those following traditional practice). It is acceptable to state the position of a movement with respect to the practice, but this must clearly identify the particular movement (i.e., "Traditional Judaism believes, not Judaism believes") and not make any judgements about that position, or individuals who do not follow that position. Discussion of emotional issues and taking care of a child after a brit are also expressly permitted. Anticipated discussions include how a brit is performed, emotional preparation for circumcision, the rituals involved, the aftermath (both medical and emotional) of circumcision, and other questions about circumcision in a Jewish context. Because of the particularly inflammatory nature of this topic, postings about circumcision will be carefully reviewed on a case-by-case basis. User Contributions:Top Document: soc.culture.jewish.parenting FAQ: Newsgroup Policies and Procedures Previous Document: 1.5. What topics are *not* appropriate for soc.culture.jewish.parenting? Next Document: 1.7. How should I respond to inappropriate articles? Single Page [ Usenet FAQs | Web FAQs | Documents | RFC Index ] Send corrections/additions to the FAQ Maintainer: SCJ FAQ Maintainer <maintainer@scjfaq.org>
Last Update March 27 2014 @ 02:11 PM
|
Comment about this article, ask questions, or add new information about this topic: