Top Document: [sci.astro] Solar System (Astronomy Frequently Asked Questions) (5/9) Previous Document: E.10 Could Jupiter become a star? Next Document: E.12 Additional planets: See reader questions & answers on this topic! - Help others by sharing your knowledge While on the face of it, this seems a reasonably easy question with a simple answer, like the "When does the 21st Century begin?" question there is no hard and fast rule, no committee of astronomers who decide these things. The best rule of thumb is that if people think something's a planet, it is. Common criteria include orbiting the Sun rather than another body (although sticklers find this troublesome) and being "large". Some have suggested using "world" as a neutral term for an interesting solar system body. The word "planet" originally meant "wanderer", so using a strict definition, everything in the solar system is a planet! When Pluto was discovered in 1930, there was no question as to whether it was a planet. The predictions made at the time imagined it to be at least the size of the Earth. As better data became available with the discovery of Pluto's moon Charon allowing the determination of a mass for Pluto, and with Pluto and Charon eclipsing each other in the late 1980's--early 1990's, it was found that Pluto is much smaller than the Earth, with a diameter of roughly 2300 km (or about 1400 mi.). In the last several years, a number of small bodies at about the same distance from the Sun as Pluto have been discovered, prompting some to call Pluto the "King of the Kuiper Belt" (the Kuiper Belt is a postulated population of comets beyond Neptune's orbit) and rally for its demotion from bona-fide planet to overgrown comet. Is Pluto a planet? It depends on what one thinks is necessary to bestow planetary status. Pluto has an atmosphere and a satellite. Of course, Titan has a much larger atmosphere, and the tiny asteroid Ida has a satellite. Most astronomers would probably consider stripping Pluto of its status akin to stripping [the U.S. states of] Connecticut or Vermont of statehood because Texas and Alaska later joined. Is Ceres a planet? Like Pluto, when it was first discovered there was no doubt that it was. Within a few years, however, Pallas, Vesta and Juno were discovered. While Ceres is the largest asteroid, the second, third and fourth largest asteroids are roughly half its size, compared to Pluto, which is about ten times larger than the Kuiper Belt objects found so far. Ceres is also not thought to have undergone large-scale geological processes such as vulcanism, although Vesta has. The consensus is probably that neither Ceres nor any other asteroid is a "planet", though they are interesting bodies in their own right. Is Titan a planet? In the 1940's a methane atmosphere was discovered around Titan, making it the only satellite with a substantial atmosphere. This atmosphere has long prevented observations of the surface, frustrating the attempts of Voyager 1 and 2 and leading theorists to suggest a Titan-wide global ocean of carbon compounds. Recent observations have been able to penetrate to the surface of Titan, showing tantalizing glimpses of what may be continents on the surface. The atmosphere combined with Titan's large size have led some to consider Titan a "planet", but what about Ganymede, which is larger, or Mercury which is smaller and has no atmosphere? Again, the general consensus is that satellites are not planets. User Contributions:Top Document: [sci.astro] Solar System (Astronomy Frequently Asked Questions) (5/9) Previous Document: E.10 Could Jupiter become a star? Next Document: E.12 Additional planets: Part0 - Part1 - Part2 - Part3 - Part4 - Part5 - Part6 - Part7 - Part8 - Single Page [ Usenet FAQs | Web FAQs | Documents | RFC Index ] Send corrections/additions to the FAQ Maintainer: jlazio@patriot.net
Last Update March 27 2014 @ 02:11 PM
|
Comment about this article, ask questions, or add new information about this topic: